About
S. Jay Dobbs is a partner at McCarthy, Leonard & Kaemmerer L.C. in Chesterfield, Missouri, with more than 25 years of trial experience. He represents businesses in complex commercial disputes, including shareholder disagreements, business valuations, construction matters, and state and local tax litigation. Jay also advises on environmental permitting and serves as outside general counsel to closely held companies. His work includes trials, arbitrations, mediation, and practical guidance when conflicts threaten business operations.
Jay earned a B.A. in Political Science from DePauw University and a J.D. from Washington University School of Law in 1991. He served as an associate editor of the Washington University Law Quarterly. Early in his legal career, he clerked for the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. He later practiced at Polsinelli, where he led litigation groups and served on the firm board. At Polsinelli, he chaired its trial department and commercial litigation practice group and served on its board of directors.
Jay has represented controlling and minority owners in business breakups and fiduciary duty claims. He handled litigation for a limestone quarry seeking a long-term mining permit and represented commercial property owners in tax assessment appeals. His real estate matters have included mortgage fraud, title defects, and a dispute that restored access to land through litigation and settlement. He has also represented company directors in disputes involving regulators and other parties.
S. Jay Dobbs has received Missouri and Kansas Super Lawyers recognition and an AV Preeminent peer rating from Martindale-Hubbell. He previously chaired a major law firm trial department and commercial litigation practice group and served on the board of the Missouri Organization of Defense Lawyers. His practice combines trial work with commercial counseling, including advice to closely held businesses on disputes over valuation, ownership, and fiduciary duties.
Law Office Affiliations
- Partner, McCarthy, Leonard & Kaemmerer L.C.
- Member, The Missouri Bar
- Member, Illinois State Bar Association
- Board Member, Missouri Organization of Defense Lawyers (MODL) (2007-2013)
- Member, ABA
- Member, MoBar
- Member, ISBA
Licensed State
- Missouri
- Illinois
Education
- Washington University School of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - DePauw University
Bachelor of Arts (BA) in Political Science
Awards & Badges



- Administrative
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Appeals
- Business
- Business Litigation
- Class Action
- Closely Held Business
- Construction & Development
- Lawsuits & Disputes
- Litigation
- Real Estate
- Tax





