About
Peter A. Pillittieri is an attorney with Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri in Jamestown, New York. His practice includes criminal law, family and matrimonial law, personal injury, and real estate. He works with individuals and families facing criminal allegations, divorce and related disputes, accidents, and property concerns. His firm serves clients in Jamestown and surrounding Chautauqua County communities.
Pillittieri earned an associate degree from Jamestown Community College and a B.A. from the State University of New York at Buffalo in 1989. He received his Juris Doctorate from the University of Akron in May 1992 and was admitted to the New York State Bar in 1993. This educational path preceded a practice encompassing both litigation and private legal transactions.
Pillittieri’s work spans criminal proceedings, family and matrimonial matters, injury claims, and real estate transactions. He assists clients with legal problems that can involve court appearances, negotiations, and important decisions about property or personal rights. Admitted to practice in U.S. federal courts as well as New York, he brings familiarity with different judicial settings to his representation of clients.
Peter A. Pillittieri is a member of the New York State Bar Association and the Jamestown Bar Association. He has also served on the Jamestown Area Midget Football Mediation Panel, reflecting involvement in community dispute resolution. His broad practice supports clients seeking a single legal adviser for matters ranging from criminal defense to family concerns and property-related issues.
Law Office Affiliations
- Attorney, Bly, Sheffield, Bargar & Pillittieri
- Member, New York State Bar Association
- Member, Jamestown Bar Association
- Member, Jamestown Area Midget Football Mediation Panel
- Member, Moonbrook Country Club
- Member, St. Mary of Lourdes Roman Catholic Church
Licensed State
- New York
Education
- University of Akron
Juris Doctor (JD) - State University of New York at Buffalo
Bachelor of Arts (BA) - Jamestown Community College
Associate’s degree
Awards & Badges

- Assault & Battery
- Criminal Defense
- Divorce & Separation
- Drug Crime
- Estate Planning
- Family
- Personal Injury
- Real Estate
- Trusts
- Wills & Living Wills




