About
Paisley S. Hoffman is a partner at Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C. in Madison, Wisconsin. She represents clients in complex criminal defense, juvenile, and family law matters. Her criminal practice includes serious felony allegations such as child abuse, sexual assault, homicide, and firearm-related offenses. She handles juvenile waiver proceedings, delinquency matters, school expulsion cases, and CHIPS cases while working to protect the interests of young clients.
Paisley earned a J.D. from the University of Wisconsin Law School in 2017, an M.S.W. from the University of Wisconsin School of Social Work in 2014, and a B.A. from the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 2012. Her social work studies focused on mental health, while her undergraduate work included legal studies and social welfare. Before practicing law, she worked with the Wisconsin Innocence Project and other community and legal organizations.
Paisley has particular experience with abusive head trauma and shaken baby syndrome allegations, including work that requires attention to child abuse pediatrics and scientific research. She has achieved pre-charging resolutions in criminal matters and represents clients in divorce, paternity, and post-judgment custody and placement disputes. Judges appoint her as Guardian ad Litem in Dane County and surrounding counties to represent children’s best interests in contested family cases.
Paisley S. Hoffman was selected for the 2026 Wisconsin Rising Stars list and has been included on the Rising Stars list each year since 2020. Her honors include the Martin Hanson Memorial Advocate’s Prize and the Kuchler-Nicholson-Stilling Award. Since January 2022, she has served as part-time faculty at Madison College, teaching Legal Writing and Family Law in the paralegal program.
Law Office Affiliations
- Partner, Nicholson Goetz & Otis, S.C.
- Member, State Bar of Wisconsin
- Secretary, Dane County Criminal Defense Lawyers Association
- Member, Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
- Member, State Bar of Wisconsin Family Law Section
- Member, Legal Association for Women
- Member, Association of Family and Conciliatory Courts
Licensed State
- Wisconsin
Education
- University of Wisconsin Law School
J.D. (12/2017) - University of Wisconsin School of Social Work
Master’s of Social Work (05/2014) - University of Wisconsin, Madison
Bachelor’s of Arts (05/2012)
Awards & Badges



- Assault & Battery
- Child Abuse & Neglect
- Child Custody
- Criminal Defense
- Divorce & Separation
- Drug Crime
- DUI & DWI
- Family
- Homicide
- Juvenile
- Paternity
- Restraining Orders
- Sex Crimes
- Violent Crime





