About
Michael Cuellar is an attorney at Spector Foerst & Associates in Millburn, New Jersey. He represents clients in personal injury matters, civil and criminal litigation, and insurance-related disputes. His practice includes automobile accidents, slip-and-fall injuries, wrongful death, workers’ compensation, insurance fraud, and criminal defense. He brings experience representing both plaintiffs and insurance interests to the evaluation and litigation of contested claims.
Cuellar earned a Bachelor of Science in Finance, magna cum laude, from Seton Hall University and his Juris Doctorate from Seton Hall School of Law. After law school, he completed a judicial clerkship with Judge Peter F. Bariso in the Hudson County Civil Division. His financial education and early exposure to civil court proceedings help inform his work on disputes involving damages, insurance coverage, and litigation strategy.
Cuellar previously handled insurance defense cases involving motor vehicle accidents, personal injury, premises liability, and coverage disputes. He later represented plaintiffs and worked on environmental torts, legal malpractice, and commercial insurance matters. After opening his own office, he managed personal injury protection arbitrations, health care matters, criminal cases, commercial collections, and insurance fraud disputes. He joined Spector Foerst & Associates in 2020.
Michael Cuellar draws on prior work with insurers, plaintiffs, and individual clients to approach litigation from several perspectives. His experience includes negotiating and litigating injury and insurance claims, examining disputed coverage, and addressing criminal allegations. This background supports his representation of clients who need to assess liability, understand litigation risks, and pursue remedies through negotiation, arbitration, or court proceedings.
Law Office Affiliations
- Attorney, Spector Foerst & Associates
- Member, New Jersey State Bar Association
- Member, New York State Bar Association
- Member, Pennsylvania Bar Association
- Member, American Trial Lawyers Association, New Jersey
- Member, American Bar Association
- Member, Bergen County Bar Association
- Member, Essex County Bar Association
- Member, Hudson County Bar Association
- Member, Morris County Bar Association
- Member, Passaic County Bar Association
Licensed State
- New Jersey
- New York
- Pennsylvania
Education
- Seton Hall School of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - Seton Hall University
Bachelor of Science (BS) in Finance (Magna Cum Laude)
Awards & Badges









- Car Accidents
- Criminal Defense
- Guardianship
- Health Care
- Insurance Claims
- Insurance Defense
- Personal Injury
- Slip & Fall Accidents
- Trucking Accidents
- Workers' Compensation
- Wrongful Death





