About
Melissa A. Natale is Of Counsel in Coughlin Midlige & Garland’s Insurance and Reinsurance Services Group in Morristown. Her practice focuses on insurance coverage counseling and litigation in state and federal courts, including matters governed by New Jersey and New York law. She advises insurers on general liability, environmental liability, property, professional liability, and excess policies, and she manages coverage disputes involving bad faith, indemnification, allocation, trigger issues, business income, and errors and omissions.
Natale earned a J.D. from Seton Hall University School of Law in 2003 and a B.A. from Fairfield University in 1995, cum laude. She began her legal career as a law clerk to the Honorable Mark M. Russello in the Civil Division of the New Jersey Superior Court, Bergen County. She is admitted in New Jersey and New York and in federal courts in New Jersey and the Eastern and Southern Districts of New York.
Natale has more than a decade of experience in insurance coverage counseling and litigation. Before joining Coughlin Midlige & Garland, she worked in a dedicated coverage group and later served as Director of Casualty Claims at Everest National Insurance Company. Her matters have included environmental contamination, first-party property claims, additional-insured issues, professional liability, and complex allocation questions. She also handles settlement negotiations and mediation as alternatives to continued litigation.
Melissa A. Natale brings private-practice and insurer-side experience to complex coverage matters. Her background in litigation, claims management, and alternative dispute resolution helps her evaluate disputes from legal and operational perspectives. She advises insurers on coverage positions, litigation strategy, settlement, and policy issues while managing matters that can involve multiple jurisdictions, parties, policy periods, and underlying claims. Her work supports practical decision-making in difficult insurance and reinsurance disputes.
Law Office Affiliations
- Of Counsel, Coughlin Midlige & Garland LLP
- Member, New Jersey State Bar Association
- Member, New York State Bar Association
- Coach and Judge, Seton Hall Law School’s Interscholastic Moot Court Board (2004-Present)
- Committee Co-Chair, Seton Hall Law Alumni Council (2011-2016)
- Volunteer for Landlord-Tenant Court, Morris County Legal Aid (2017-2018)
Licensed State
- New Jersey
- New York
Education
- Seton Hall University School of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - Fairfield University
Bachelor of Arts (BA) (Cum Laude)
Awards & Badges


- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Car Accidents
- Insurance
- Insurance Claims
- Insurance Defense
- Lawsuits & Disputes
- Personal Injury
- Products Liability
- Professional Liability
- Trucking Accidents
- Wrongful Death





