About
K. Robert Toy is an attorney at Toy & Associates in Athens, Ohio, with extensive courtroom experience in criminal defense and related litigation. His work includes felony and misdemeanor defense in state and federal courts, and the firm also handles family law and student defense matters. He is certified by the Ohio Supreme Court to serve as lead counsel in capital cases and has practiced before the U.S. Supreme Court and the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio.
Robert earned a B.A. from Miami University in Oxford, Ohio, and received a J.D. from the University of Toledo College of Law. During law school, he served as Chief Justice of the Student Judiciary Council. His legal education prepared him for a career that has included prosecution, public service, trial practice, and defense work. He maintains memberships in criminal defense, trial lawyer, state bar, and local bar organizations.
Robert served as an Assistant Prosecuting Attorney for Athens County from 1978 to 1992 and received a statewide Outstanding Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Award. In 1992, he was appointed Athens County Prosecuting Attorney to complete an unexpired term. He has served as a special prosecutor in several Ohio counties. His trial record includes more than 200 jury trials, including more than 20 murder trials, along with hundreds of contested divorce and custody cases.
K. Robert Toy brings knowledge from both prosecution and defense to serious criminal cases. His experience includes capital matters, murder trials, other felony and misdemeanor cases, and extensive domestic relations litigation. He has also instructed police officers on constitutional law and legal procedure and has served municipalities and public entities in legal roles. His background gives clients representation informed by decades of courtroom work, public service, and direct experience with the strategies used in criminal prosecutions.
Law Office Affiliations
- Attorney, Toy Law Office LLC
- Member, Ohio State Bar Association
- Member, Ohio Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
- Member, Association of Trial Lawyers of America
- Member, Athens County Bar Association
- Board Member, Athens County Historical Society
- Member, Athens Kiwanis Club
- Member, Athens Area Chamber of Commerce
- Solicitor, Village of Glouster
- Solicitor, City of Nelsonville
- Corporate Attorney, Sunday Creek Water District
Licensed State
- Ohio
Education
- University of Toledo College of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - Miami University
Bachelor of Arts (BA)
Awards & Badges



- Assault & Battery
- Child Custody
- Criminal Defense
- Divorce & Separation
- Driver's License Suspension
- Drug Crime
- DUI & DWI
- Homicide
- Juvenile
- Sex Crimes
- Violent Crime





