About
Donald C. Prentiss is a partner at Hornthal, Riley, Ellis & Maland, LLP in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, with more than three decades of civil litigation experience. His practice includes insurance defense, motor vehicle cases, premises liability, personal injury claims, and commercial or contract disputes. He represents individuals and businesses in contested matters and also helps injured people pursue damages. Prentiss brings extensive trial experience to cases involving liability, insurance coverage concerns, injuries, and business disagreements.
Prentiss earned a J.D. from Wake Forest University, School of Law in 1981 and a B.A. from Wake Forest University in 1977. He was a member of Phi Delta Phi during law school. His education provided a foundation for litigation involving evidence, tort claims, contracts, and courtroom procedure. He is admitted in North Carolina and in federal courts including the Eastern and Middle Districts of North Carolina and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.
Prentiss has spent much of his career handling insurance defense matters and civil disputes across North Carolina. His experience includes motor vehicle and premises liability cases, personal injury claims, and commercial and contract litigation for individuals and businesses. He is also a certified Superior Court mediator, allowing him to work with parties seeking resolution outside trial. His background across defense, injury, and business matters helps him assess factual records, liability questions, damages, and litigation strategy from multiple perspectives.
Donald C. Prentiss holds an AV rating from Martindale-Hubbell and is a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers. He has received the North Carolina Bar Association Citizen Lawyer Award and has served on the North Carolina State Bar Disciplinary Hearing Commission. His professional involvement includes the First Judicial District Bar, where he formerly served as president, and organizations focused on trial and defense practice. He combines courtroom experience, mediation skills, and practical civil litigation judgment.
Law Office Affiliations
- Partner, Hornthal, Riley, Ellis & Maland
- Councilor, The North Carolina State Bar (2004-2013)
- Chair, North Carolina State Bar Disciplinary Hearing Commission (2019-2022)
- Former President, First Judicial District Bar
- Board Member, North Carolina Association of Defense Attorneys
- Board Member, Legal Services of N.C. (1990-1995)
- Member, American Bar Association
- Member, Litigation Section
- Member, Tort Trial and Insurance Practice
- Member, United States District Court, Eastern District of North Carolina
- Member, United States District Court, Middle District of North Carolina
- Member, United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
- Board Member, Client Security Fund (2001-2005)
- Former Chairman, Food Bank of the Albemarle, Board of Directors (1990-1999)
- Member, Defense Research Institutes
- Member, Phi Delta Phi
- Member, Christ Episcopal Church
- Member, Albemarle Economic Development Commission
- Member, BB&T Bank, Board of Directors
- Member, Elizabeth City Area Chamber of Commerce, Board of Directors
- Member, Elizabeth City Morning Rotary Club
Licensed State
- North Carolina
Education
- Wake Forest University School of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - Wake Forest University
Bachelor of Arts (BA)
Awards & Badges




- Animal & Dog Bites
- Car Accidents
- Insurance Defense
- Lawsuits & Disputes
- Litigation
- Medical Malpractice
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Personal Injury
- Products Liability
- Slip & Fall Accidents
- Trucking Accidents
- Wrongful Death





