About
Catherine E. Nagel is a Partner at Nuchereno & Nagel who concentrates most of her practice on matrimonial and family law. She handles divorce and post-divorce proceedings, child custody, support, and visitation matters, and she regularly advocates in New York Supreme, Family, and Surrogate’s Courts. Her practice also includes wills, estate planning, and estate proceedings, giving clients access to counsel across related family and planning needs.
Nagel earned a B.A., summa cum laude, from SUNY at Buffalo and was elected to Phi Beta Kappa. She later received a J.D., cum laude, from SUNY at Buffalo School of Law. Her academic record and legal training support a practice that combines litigation, family-law analysis, estate planning, and negotiation. She has been admitted to practice since 1999 and is admitted in federal courts and before the U.S. Supreme Court.
Nagel is an experienced trial attorney and also supports clients seeking alternatives to courtroom litigation. She is a trained Mediator and Collaborative Lawyer and participates in organizations devoted to collaborative practice. Her work includes contested and negotiated family matters, post-divorce issues, custody and support disputes, estate proceedings, and out-of-court resolution. She also participates in the Fourth Judicial Department’s Attorney for the Children Panel.
Catherine E. Nagel has held leadership roles in the legal community, including past chair of the Erie County Bar Association’s Matrimonial and Family Law Committee. She has served on the Civil Practice Law and Rules Advisory Committee to New York’s Chief Judge and has presented for bar associations and community organizations. Her work combines courtroom experience, mediation training, estate-planning knowledge, and practical guidance for families facing major legal transitions.
Law Office Affiliations
- Partner, Nuchereno & Nagel, PLLC
- Member, New York State Bar Association
- Past Chair, Matrimonial and Family Law Committee, Bar Association of Erie County
- Committed Participant, NYS 4th Judicial Department’s Attorney for the Children Panel
- Member, Erie County Surrogate’s Court Liaison Committee
- Member, Western New York Collaborative Law Professionals Ltd.
- Past President, Erie County Aid to Indigent Prisoner’s Society
- Member, International Association of Collaborative Professionals
- Member, Orchard Park Symphony Orchestra
- Member, Lutheran Church Extension Society
Licensed State
- New York
Education
- The University at Buffalo School of Law
Juris Doctor (JD) - The State University of New York at Buffalo
Bachelor of Arts (BA)
Awards & Badges

- Alimony
- Alternative Dispute Resolution
- Child Custody
- Child Support
- Civil Rights
- Commercial Real Estate
- Divorce & Separation
- Elder Law
- Estate Planning
- Family
- Guardianship
- Health Care
- Lawsuits & Disputes
- Litigation
- Mediation & Collaborative Law
- Probate
- Real Estate
- Trusts
- Wills & Living Wills





