Anthony S. Pinnie

Anthony Pinnie, Esq., is a Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and District of Columbia attorney focusing on civil trial work, auto accidents, general and commercial litigation, medical malpractice, products liability, insurance bad faith, premises liability, professional negligence, ERISA, and disability issues. His work supports plaintiffs and defendants facing injury claims, insurance disputes, business conflicts, and complex litigation requiring courtroom preparation and trial strategy.

Anthony S. Pinnie earned a J.D. from Widener University School of Law. He also earned a B.A. from Lehigh University. His education supports legal research, trial preparation, case evaluation, evidence analysis, and client counseling. He uses that background to assess liability, review records, prepare witnesses, develop arguments, negotiate settlements, and present cases involving products, professional negligence, disability benefits, and personal injury disputes.

Anthony has tried more than 100 jury cases and obtained many favorable verdicts for clients. He appears primarily in Delaware County courts and also litigates in Chester, Montgomery, and Philadelphia Counties. His federal court work includes handling multidistrict litigation for mass tort matters. Before his current role, he served as a senior in-house litigation counsel for AIG, handling complex insurance litigation and property damage recovery cases.

Anthony S. Pinnie helps clients approach civil disputes with trial experience, practical judgment, and strong preparation. His work includes defective product claims, automobile liability, medical malpractice, professional negligence, premises liability, insurance bad faith, ERISA matters, and disability issues. He has negotiated several seven-figure settlements and is admitted in multiple state, federal district, and bankruptcy courts, giving clients broad litigation experience across demanding forums. His approach emphasizes early evaluation before trial or settlement decisions arise.

Law Office Affiliations

• Attorney, Schuster Law
• Member, Pennsylvania Bar Association
• Member, Bar Association of the District of Columbia
• Member, New Jersey State Bar Association

Licensed State

• Pennsylvania
• New Jersey
• District of Columbia

Education

• Widener University School of Law
  Juris Doctor (JD)
• Lehigh University
  Bachelor of Arts (BA)

Awards & Badges